JOIN MICELLA PHOENIX DeWHYSE–GRAD STUDENT EXTRAORDINAIRE–AS SHE MAKES HER WAY THROUGH GRAD SCHOOL IN MATERIALS SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING
Why is it that we, as scientists, are taught that communication of our science is essential for success, but somehow communication with others, for general well-being and harmony, is left in the dust?
I mean, think about it: We’ve all seen seminars on how to write effectively, how to present effectively, but rarely do we see anything geared toward educators and the educated on how to communicate effectively in a nonscientific context and how to relate to one another. And I believe that lots of the conflict that we experience, in lab and in life, happens because we simply have not learned how to communicate.
When I say “communicate,” I mean a variety of things. First of all, to me, communicating effectively involves more than just talking. It also includes listening. Further, it involves body language, tone, inflection, motive, perspective, culture, and a whole host of other things that most people just don’t take into account when conversing. Have you ever thought for a minute that everyone doesn’t operate the same way you do?
That’s a novel concept for some of us. Different people interpret these things in different ways. The same sentence said to three different people will be heard to have three different meanings, even if the inflection and body language are the same. The person who knows the speaker best will probably come closest to understanding what the speaker is trying to say.
This is why PIs need to get to know their students outside of the lab and understand what kind of backgrounds they are coming from. PIs just might want to know what kind of behaviors their students normally exhibit–outgoing versus shy, rambunctious versus calm, angry and bitter versus sublimely happy (if that even exists)–and how to respond appropriately.
I know this all seems like common sense to some of you, but you’d be amazed how often we scientists put other scientists and engineers into a box and assume that they will conform to the image we have of them. I think we all do it, unless we work at not doing it. If they don’t conform to your image, and they’re not comfortable fitting into the box, why would they stick around?
As scientists, we tend to pretend that needs, wants, emotions, relationships, ego, and so on, don’t matter–it’s all about the science, right?–when in reality they can be a large factor in the political games we play, just like everyone else does. We want to think that it’s about working with the purity of the subject, increasing knowledge, and solving the world’s problems. Yet the more successful particular scientists are and the more clout they have, the more likely it is that they can do as they please, run over people, and make lives hellish with little or no regard for consequences.
Back to this communication thing: We all, students and PIs, must learn to do it better. If we could step outside of ourselves for a moment and truly listen to the things we say, and think about how we are perceived, and have a decent dialogue with others about such a thing, that would be a step in the right direction. For those of you thinking “I’m fine just how I am,” think for a minute about your interactions and relationships. Are they strained? Do you think this is because everyone is against you? Are you always right? If people really upset you, do you tell them why? Or do you just stop talking to them?
Maybe I’m completely off my rocker here, but I believe in a sort of karma: The universe will give you back what you expect and what you put out. Yes, graduate school, and life in general, are hard, and sometimes we all want to quit. Have you checked your state of mind lately? If it’s all bad, and you have absolutely no joy … are you spending any time looking for it?
Enough of my diatribe. Next time: concrete ways to improve communication with each other, as people and as scientists.
If you have examples of how effective communication, or lack of it, improved or ruined your life in the lab, feel free to share, and I’ll pass it on. Until then, let’s all think about what we say and how we say it. And smile, daggumit! It doesn’t hurt. …
Micella can be reached via email at .